Friday, September 11, 2009

Unnoticed Hypocrisy at the "You Lie" Speech


"Some of people's concerns have grown out of bogus claims spread by those whose only agenda is to kill reform at any cost. The best example is the claim, made not just by radio and cable talk show hosts, but prominent politicians, that we plan to set up panels of bureaucrats with the power to kill off senior citizens. Such a charge would be laughable if it weren't so cynical and irresponsible. It is a lie, plain and simple. [Rousing cheers, sustained applause]

There are also those who claim that our reform effort will insure illegal immigrants. This, too, is false – the reforms I'm proposing would not apply to those who are here illegally.* ~Obama

*"You lie!" ~Representative Joe Wilson [Boos and faces of anger and shock, soon followed by days of controversy]


So, Obama calling out liars in politics and the private sector (multiple times) is met by cheers, but a congressman calling out a liar (once) is met by jeers?

Ah, Democracy!

10 comments:

LSP said...

Nice point S3.

Son3 said...

Thank you, LSP!

Y'all come back, now!

Y'hear?

Johann Van De Leeuw said...

Yessir!
We all's hyere.
To your poll - absolutely!
I haven't watched the video below,
as it's over an hour long and I haven't time. But I plan to watch it with my dad when I get a chance. Probably not tonight, as M&J are coming over.

Son3 said...

Okay, thanks!

How are M&J doing?

Johann Van De Leeuw said...

They're doing great! They're living about 20 minutes from us.
What'd y'all do for labor day?
BTW, we put our flag at halfmast in remembrance of 9/11, and in protest of the Patriot and National Security Acts.
Keep up the good work!
~Johann

Liberty said...

A good point, but still not proof of anything much.

Not to be rude, but I'm still waiting for proof of some of the allegations against this bill I've seen- I'd be more than happy to believe anything horrid of this bill, but most of the allegations (death panels, illegals getting healthcare, abortions being funded, etc.) have not been proven.

Son3 said...

Johann, I don't recall what we did for Labor Day. We really don't do much stuff on Communist holidays. :)

Liberty, I'll do some research and pull up my references ASAP, so check back soon.

Nevertheless, I don't know why these allegations need to be made in the first place, as the bill violates the Constitution.

The powers given to Congress are all-inclusive, and control of medicine is not among those powers.

A Constitutional case can be made for state-implemented health care, or private sector, but not federal.

CarolineNot said...

Susan Larson, registered nurse at Mayo Clinic and seeming proponent of the health care bill: “In regard to Section 1233 of the proposed health care bill, medical caregivers are instructed to have discussions with seniors about their end-of-life care, at least every five years, or yearly if the medical condition of the patient makes significant changes or they develop a chronic illness.” She goes on to praise this.

See page 6 of Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel's Principles for allocation of scarce medical interventions. Dr. Emanuel is a health policy advisor to Barack Obama and the brother of of the chief of staff.

Death panels. No one will find those words in HR 3200, so there's no need to look for them. One must be able to discern the character and intent of individuals and groups and have an understanding of a much broader picture than HR 3200. On this particular -- and comparatively insignificant issue -- my personal response is to be incensed that I will be required to carry health insurance (or pay a penalty), and a physician will be required to repeatedly draw my attention to how old and decrepit I am becoming. Don't forget you're going to die! One might do well to draw more attention to how I'm living what's going to happen after I die. Wrong focus.

Moreover -- and I realize this is not an academic statement, but grandiose verbiage tends to flatter and puff-up an author more than conveying a message -- to what depths have we sunk, when the debate is over whether or not this bill impacts or addresses the already dishonored elderly, murdered babies, and invaders of our country? Why do those groups exist in our nation in the first place?

Finally, I'm sorry, Son3, for blathering so on your blog while you're still sleeping. I know and understand that the minutia of this issue vexes you, since -- as you educated me -- the whole thing is unconstitutional in the first place. All these issues are heart problems, resolved one heart at a time.

Dr. Paleo Ph.D. said...

"Ah, Democracy!"

Ah, I think you meant Obamocracy?

Son3 said...

Uh-oh! I think someone just made up a new t-shirt!

Websites That Make This One Possible

Ideations of a Jayhawker: Blog Policies

Comments
No vulgar, obscene, vile, or inappropriate language or insinuation may be used, and comments are subject to editing or deletion at my own discretion.

Please use proper spelling, following the rules of grammar of the English language.

The elimination of comments due to an objectionable account image may also be used at my discretion. Links given in comments that direct one to a website containing evil or unsightly content will also be deleted at my discretion.

Advocating or promoting specific acts of violence isn't allowed, but the vitriolic spewing of rants and ravings is encouraged.

Content

Content found in this blog is public domain, and it may be used freely; permission to recreate is automatically given, I only ask that I be informed when it is copied on another website; though this is not required, it would be considered a kind gesture.

Content found at any other website that was linked to from this page is beyond my control. I strive to put out as little objectionable content as possible here, but if you do find something that you feel is inappropriate, please contact me via comment, and I will duly edit it to a degree I deem appropriate.

Quotes you may find are all sic, including spelling, grammar, etc.

Following
Followers of this blog are more than welcome, but if you have a website that routinely displays content that you wouldn't allow a child to view or read, do not follow this blog unless you have a blogger warning previous to entering your website.
Failure to do so may result in being blocked from the followers list.

A follower may also be blocked if your account image is found to be objectionable.